BEIJING -A broad array of Chinese data on Tuesday highlighted intensifying pressure on the economy from multiple fronts, prompting Beijing to cut key policy rates to shore up activity but analysts say more support is needed to revitalize growth.
Just before the release of a batch of July data, China’s central bank unexpectedly chopped one set of key interest rates, and followed it with cuts on other rates hours later, underlining the rapid loss of the post-COVID economic rebound that has shaken global financial markets.
Tuesday’s data released by the National Bureau of Statistics (NBS), which comes on top of a raft of weak indicators from last week, showed retail sales, industrial output and investment all growing at a slower than expected pace – indicating the engines of business and consumption in the world’s second-biggest economy were severely underpowered.
Additionally, China suspended publishing youth jobless data, which hit a record high of 21.3% in June.
“All the main activity indicators undershot consensus expectations in July, with most either stagnant or barely expanding in month on month terms,” said Julian Evans-Pritchard, economist at Capital Economics.
“And with financial troubles at developers such as Country Garden likely to weigh on the housing market in the near-term, there is a real risk of the economy slipping into a recession unless policy support is ramped up soon.”
Nomura analysts were equally downbeat on China’s economic outlook.
“We believe the Chinese economy is faced with an imminent downward spiral with the worst yet to come, and the rate cut this morning will be of limited help,” they said.
Most economists see downside risk to Chinese growth but they do not expect a recession.
Industrial output grew 3.7 percent from a year earlier, slowing from the 4.4 percent pace seen in June, the NBS data showed, and was below expectations for a 4.4- percent increase in a Reuters poll of analysts.
Retail sales, a gauge of consumption, rose 2.5 percent, down from a 3.1- percent increase in June and missed analysts’ forecasts of 4.5 percent growth despite the summer travel season.
It was the slowest growth since December 2022, showing how much of a challenge authorities face as they try to make consumption the key driver of future economic growth.
More stimulus
Asian stocks stalled at one-month lows, the yuan hit a 9-month nadir while the dollar held broadly firm after the weak Chinese data and latest policy easing measures.
Following the first rate cuts, China’s major state-owned banks were seen selling U.S. dollars and buying yuan in a bid to stem rapid declines in the currency, three people with direct knowledge of the matter said. Sovereign bond yields fell to three-year lows, and benchmark stock indexes were down.
Record-low credit growth and rising deflation risks in July necessitated more monetary easing measures to arrest the slowdown, market watchers said, while default risks at some housing developers and missed payments by a private wealth manager also soured market confidence.
Nie Wen, an economist at Hwabao Trust, expects special bonds to be introduced urgently and said the probability of a reserve requirement ratio (RRR) cut in the short run is relatively large.
Policymakers last month released a batch of stimulus measures, from boosting auto and home appliances consumption, relaxing some property restrictions to pledging support to the private sector, as a post-COVID rebound rapidly lost steam since the second quarter.
The catering sector, which reaped benefits from the COVID reopening, saw slower revenue growth in July from June. Investment in the private sector shrank 0.5 percent in the first seven months, extending 0.2 percent decline in the first half of 2023.
Structural pains
The persistent drag in the property sector, mounting local government debt pressure, high youth jobless rate and cooling foreign demand continue to be major impediments to fostering a sustainable economic revival.
China is undergoing a painful transition to a less debt-fueled, less property-centric and more consumer-driven economy, said Robert Carnell, Asia-Pacific head of research at ING.
“We will continue to see weak macro data for the foreseeable future. It is a necessary part of the adjustment and is far preferable to resurrecting the debt-fueled property model that propelled growth previously. But we do need to lower our expectations for China’s growth.”
Other data on Tuesday showed fixed asset investment expanded 3.4 percent in the first seven months of 2023 from the same period a year earlier, versus expectations for a 3.8-percent rise. It grew 3.8 percent in the January-June period.
Investment in the property sector tumbled 8.5 percent year-on-year in January-July, after shrinking 7.9 percent in January-June, extending its fall for the 17th consecutive month.
The nationwide survey-based jobless rate climbed slightly to 5.3 percent from 5.2 percent in June. Among OECD members, the average unemployment rate was 4.8 percent , with youth joblessness around 10 percent .
China set its 2023 growth target at around 5 percent , but Nomura analysts warn the country could miss the goal again as it did last year.
“We also see bigger downside risk to our 4.9 percent y-o-y growth forecast for both Q3 and Q4, and it is increasingly possible that annual GDP growth this year will miss the 5 percent mark.”
($1 = 7.2838 Chinese yuan renminbi)