Quantcast
Latest Stories

Banana industry fears loss of China trade over Scarborough row

By

PHOTO BY PINOY GONZALES/PDI CONTRIBUTOR

DAVAO CITY — Banana industry leaders here fear the political tension between the Philippines and China over the Panatag (Scarborough) Shoal may eventually take a toll on the country’s multimillion-dollar banana industry.

Stephen Antig, president of the Pilipino Banana Growers and Exporters Association (Pbgea), said that China, the biggest buyer of Philippine Cavendish bananas, recently imposed tighter rules on incoming banana shipments.

China has reportedly denied that the stricter rules had anything to do with the current military standoff over the shoal between the two countries but banana industry leaders remain jittery.

A shipload of bananas from the Philippines was recently rejected by China because it reportedly failed quarantine tests, Antig said.

The rejection, he added, sent jitters through the banana industry in Mindanao, which is made up of about 18 companies, because it was “unusual.”

The Philippines has been exporting Cavendish there for over a decade now, he said.

Advanced technology

Antig would not divulge the name of the company that sent the rejected bananas but said that other companies in Mindanao used the most advanced high-end technology to process their products.

“We have been very careful in shipping bananas to China and seeing to it that there is no problem,” he said.

“We recently held a meeting and shared the same apprehension that we may lose the valuable market in China as a result of the dispute over the shoal,” Antig said.

He said the Department of Trade and Industry had reportedly  asked Chinese authorities if there were plans to stop imports from the Philippines.

The answer was “it’s not yet happening,” Antig said.

“But anything can happen and we are keeping a close watch,” he added.

Moved only now

While China has the right to impose stricter quarantine controls, Antig said they could not but note that the move came in the wake of the shoal dispute.

“It is only now that they have become stricter or more stringent,” he said.

China is now the largest consumer of Philippine Cavendish bananas. Of the estimated 75 million boxes that banana companies shop overseas each year, “more than half goes to China,” according to Antig. ” [It’s] much bigger than Japan,” he added.

Antig believes that if the Philippines loses the China banana market, it would trigger the economic downfall of the banana industry.

The Panatag Shoal issue may be viewed as  political but it could have a devastating effect on trade relations between the country and China, Antig said.


Follow Us


Follow us on Facebook Follow on Twitter Follow on Twitter


Recent Stories:

Complete stories on our Digital Edition newsstand for tablets, netbooks and mobile phones; 14-issue free trial. About to step out? Get breaking alerts on your mobile.phone. Text ON INQ BREAKING to 4467, for Globe, Smart and Sun subscribers in the Philippines.

Short URL: http://business.inquirer.net/?p=57811

Tags: Banana , Business , China , dispute , industries , Scarborough , Scarborough Shoal , Trade , West Philippine Sea

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_W6BSQWWPOC6TYK4QLMVYJHPFMA sov

    I do not know why we feel doom and gloom about this.  China is not the only country in the world that we can do business with.   Frankly, I do not believe that China has helped the world from the 2008 recession.  The only thing that they did was to helped themselves of cheap opportunities and selling their wares at a high price. 

    • PurpleDaisy13

      re: “I do not know why we feel doom and gloom about this”

      Because you are not in touch with reality. 

      There are millions of products made from China being used by millions of people in the Philippines.  Whether or not they are of low or high quality products, people rely on them for their daily needs and for their basic survival.  While many Philippine businesses rely on them to sell on the market, to remain open for the public, to provide people jobs, income, and a chance for a bright future.

      If a war of economic sanctions begin, all China-made products will cease to enter the Philippines.  While all Philippine-made products will cease to be sold in China.

      By the time both countries have officially engaged in economic sanctions against each other, everything I’ve mentioned will be at serious risk.  the Philippines economy will have difficulties and problems looking for other trading partners as everything around them begin to crumble.

      • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_W6BSQWWPOC6TYK4QLMVYJHPFMA sov

         The only thing i can say is think out of the box.  If you have a good financial manager.  What will  they tell you?  Diversify.  This is what the Philippines should do.  In our case,  Diversify our goods at different markets.  Besides, I am a believer of the Rule of Law.  Issues of trade or trade wars.  Try WTO. That’s all!

      • PurpleDaisy13

        re: “Besides, I am a believer of the Rule of Law.”

        If you are a believer of the Rule of Law, then if a particular country becomes the first to institutes a Law of the Sea within the South China Sea, would you adhere to that law?

      • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_W6BSQWWPOC6TYK4QLMVYJHPFMA sov

         I’ll tell you then when such laws are pass.  But right now.  It’s wait and see.

      • PurpleDaisy13

        Such law had already been declared internationally since the 1940s, in which not one of the South East Asian countries have objected to for thirty (30) years. 

        Would you adhere to this Rule of Law?

    • universalbeing

      We should ask our friend, the US, to help us by increasing their banana intake from 1 per day to 3 per day per individual, followed by a whole pineapple. If they are our friend, they should never refuse.

  • justbragging

    This was already a news the other day. Why was this reposted? Why do I get the feeling that this article wants to inject fear to the public?

    • PurpleDaisy13

      Because the public should fear the possibilities of economic sanctions that will destroy the Philippine economy, bring chaos, poverty, and suffering to the whole nation all because of some stupid fishing spot dispute the Philippines is trying to steal from China.

      • universalbeing

        my god ! china don’t even need to militarize this conflict. They just stop buying bananas for 3 days and already we feel tremors in our economy. How shameful ! how shameful ! what can we do ?

      • PurpleDaisy13

        re: “my god ! china don’t even need to militarize this conflict.”

        Many leaders and Filipinos knew this was coming but were too dumb and many refused to recognize that the whole fishing spot dispute is just plain silly to be fighting over….especially when it is easy to see the major consequences this could do for the whole economy and stability of the Philippines.

        And most importantly, many never took the time to understand that Philippines never owned Huangyan region (Scarborough Shoals)..and that China owned all of the islands and reefs since they internationally declared in the 1940s.

        What Filipinos can do is recognize China’s FIRST Law of the Sea instituted in the 1940s concerning THEIR South China Sea region…then RESPECT IT..and HONOR IT.

        Unlike UNCLOS, ITLOS, EZZ, 200 nautical-mile cr*p that aimed to conflict with China’s first Law of the Sea in the 1970s in which Philippines only ratified in 1984.

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_NPON5WTAIOOBJE52P74TNVO3OU noel

    ganon di paalisin na natin mga negosyanteng intsik sa pinas para palitan na lang natin ng sariling atin mas maganda pa para uyumaman naman ang mga pinoy kasalanan kasi ng mga pinuno natin sa konting suhol ayan dumami ng intsik sa bansa natin…….dapat tulungan tayo ng gobyerno na magtayo ng sariling negosyo natin tignan mo ang mga intsik dahil communista sila ang gobyerno ang nagbibigay ng puhunan para sa gobyerno din nila ang kita………….kaya yong mga intsik sa bansa nila kawawa sila pero ang gobyerno napakayaman.

  • Guest

    Going Banana?…. dito nila export sa middle east kulang na kulang ang saging dito meron man pero di masarap. sigurado dami bili nyan dahil dami x-pat dito. come on guys( from Davao) think outside the box!!!

  • Ben Tampadong

    O sige na , ibigay na natin yung Panatag para mabenta na yung banana? Unggoy…

    • mountainecho

      That’s not the alternative choice to be made.  Bilateral trade can be preserved and even built up simply by ending the standoff by both sides pulling out and reverting to prior status quo.  The Philippines will then have time to develop its economy and build up its national defense.  Look, this is the path followed by China in the decade of the eighties, when China under Deng drastically cut its army and defense budget and focus on nation building.  One cannot have a strong military without a prosperous economy.  The collapse of Soviet Union under the weight of defense over-spending provides another good lesson.  Just remember, getting the Scarborough Shoal back to its peaceful state does not mean giving it up.  Starting the incident with warship arresting fishermen and trying to force a dormant issue to a head risk losing the Shoal completely.  That’s dumb.

  • mountainecho

    Should a trade war erupts, the Philippines will suffer disproportionately. According to DFA citing China custom data, “GACC statistics revealed that trade between the two countries during the first half of 2010 was in favor of the Philippines, as China’s exports to the Philippines was valued at US$5.6 billion, while China’s imports from the Philippines was pegged at $7.5 billion.”

    On top of that, China’s share of world trade far dwarfs that of the Philippines, making the loss of bilateral trade impacting the PH much more than China. Losing the trade will feel like losing a pound of flesh to the Philippines, but only a mosquito sting to China.

    • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_I5WCQRDKQRIUTJAYVC5SHVFAWY marcelo III

      Everything has a trade off. Freedom has a high cost.
      I think we can find other markets for our Banana’s. We can also further explore other uses for bananas to help the industry.  And if indeed our Banana stands out, Chinese will buy them by hook or by crook.
      As to the $7.5 B amount of export’s Philippines does to China, How many percent are the banana’s? I presume that the bulk amount is more on our minerals like ore, copper & gold. If we stop trading with them we’ll loose our revenue from China but, in return we’ll gain more on preserving our own resources for our own use, not being dependent to China and Respect.

      • PurpleDaisy13

        re: “Freedom has a high cost.”

        Exactly who’s freedom is being violated in Huangyan region (Scarborough Shoal)?

        Can you give us the names of 3 Filipino residents that are losing their freedom at the Huangyan region (Scarborough Shoals)?

        1) Name _________________
        2) Name _________________
        3) Name _________________



Copyright © 2013, .
To subscribe to the Philippine Daily Inquirer newspaper in the Philippines, call +63 2 896-6000 for Metro Manila and Metro Cebu or email your subscription request here.
Factual errors? Contact the Philippine Daily Inquirer's day desk. Believe this article violates journalistic ethics? Contact the Inquirer's Reader's Advocate. Or write The Readers' Advocate:
c/o Philippine Daily Inquirer Chino Roces Avenue corner Yague and Mascardo Streets, Makati City, Metro Manila, Philippines Or fax nos. +63 2 8974793 to 94
Advertisement

News

  • 16 – 3 still equals Senate victory
  • Comelec to charge destroyers of CF cards
  • Security agency loses P120,000 to burglars
  • Cops looking for 2 teens who robbed bus
  • Did you know: Pascual Poblete
  • Sports

  • Bora Rum five safely through
  • Austria: SMB streak no ABL title guarantee
  • Dolar, Briones top aerobic gymnastics
  • Mariano grabs No. 1 seeding
  • Ortile, Enriquez shine
  • Lifestyle

  • Should we parents keep secrets from our kids?
  • Creative sisters concoct a Pinoy-themed treat for Mother’s Day
  • Has the helmet law been forgotten so soon?
  • Globe Tattoo and Stöckinger: Powerful, speedy team-up
  • The pope and the devil: Is Francis an exorcist?
  • Entertainment

  • Justin Bieber’s pet monkey becomes ‘German’
  • Tardy star makes supporting actor lose job
  • TV5 wishes Willie Revillame ‘well in new pursuits’
  • Ai-Ai de las Alas plans to file for divorce
  • Sarah Jessica Parker: I shop with my eyes, too
  • Business

  • Prudentialife pPlan holders want liquidation deferred
  • McCafe rolls out new smoothie
  • Accidental find shows Vitamin C kills tuberculosis
  • Asia shares mixed ahead of Bernanke testimony
  • Finance slams TRO on oil smuggling case
  • Technology

  • Microsoft readies new Xbox as entertainment hub
  • Yahoo! vows not to ruin Tumblr after $1.1B takeover
  • Yahoo! confirms Tumblr deal for $1.1B
  • Mobiles offer financial lifeline to Asian migrants—study
  • Metro’s traffic situation may now be monitored via smart phones, tablets
  • Opinion

  • Editorial cartoon, May 22, 2013
  • Stranglehold
  • Dark side
  • Philippine elections split rather than unite
  • Admin, European business group not on same page
  • Global Nation

  • Civil groups taking poll plaints to UN
  • Aquino bares AFP buildup vs ‘bullies in our backyard’
  • Taipei releases satellite record, rejecting Manila’s claim
  • Aquino: We can fight back vs any threat
  • No Filipino injuries, deaths reported in Oklahoma tornado
  • Marketplace
    Advertisement
    © Copyright 1997-2013 INQUIRER.net | All Rights Reserved
    skinner left
    skinner right