Palawan’s mining moratorium goes against Constitution, says group

MANILA, Philippines – The Philippine Nickel Industry Association (PNIA) said Palawan went beyond its mandate in issuing a 50-year mining moratorium in the province, thus undermining the Constitution and the country’s position in the global market.

In a statement on Friday, PNIA said the ban on new mining operations “represents an overreach of local police power,” as the local ordinance lacks proper legal and regulatory basis.

READ: Palawan approves 50-year ban on new mining permits

“By imposing such a blanket ban without sufficient legal foundation or consultation with national stakeholders, it undermines the balance between local autonomy and national oversight, which is an essential element for sustainable and equitable development,” the group said.

PNIA said the mining ban also sends a “damaging” signal to both local and international investors, hampering economic opportunities in the province and weakening the country’s competitiveness in the global nickel market.

‘Drastic policy’

“Such a drastic policy adds unnecessary uncertainty to the sector, undermining the industry’s consistent advocacy for predictable, stable policies that support long-term investments and competitiveness,” the group added.

The Department of Environment and Natural Resources and the PNIA both did not respond to further queries.

During a special session held on Wednesday, the Sangguniang Panlalawigan (provincial board) approved to freeze the issuance of endorsements for all large- and small-scale mining applications, including applications for exploration permits, mineral agreements and financial or technical agreements in Palawan.

Instead of imposing “an impractical and far-reaching moratorium,” PNIA proposed enhancing the regulatory framework to promote responsible mining operations.

According to the PNIA, this can be achieved by harmonizing national and local policies on managing natural resources, creating a transparent policy framework to encourage investment in sustainable mining technologies and reinforcing strict environmental standards.

The group expressed its readiness to collaborate with the provincial government to find a way forward, adding that mining projects in Palawan, which support key sectors such as infrastructure, logistics and small businesses, comply with stringent environmental standards.

“We advocate for constructive dialogue between the government, local communities and industry players to create policies that promote both economic growth and environmental sustainability,” it added.