At halfway point, next challenges loom for ECB's Lagarde | Inquirer Business

At halfway point, next challenges loom for ECB’s Lagarde

/ 09:45 AM November 02, 2023

FRANKFURT, Germany  -Halfway through an eight-year stint as head of the European Central Bank, Christine Lagarde has cause to cheer as inflation finally slows after an unprecedented streak of interest rate hikes.

But the conundrum of how to further tame prices without crashing the eurozone economy looks set to dominate the second part of her term.

Eurozone inflation dropped to a surprise two-year low of 2.9 percent in October, inching closer to the ECB’s two-percent target and down from more than 10 percent a year ago after Russia’s war in Ukraine sent energy costs soaring.


The slowdown was mainly due to falling energy prices, yet the news will likely bolster the ECB’s case that it was right to hold rates steady last week after 10 successive increases.


But Lagarde and her team aren’t out of the woods yet — and new risks are piling up.

The ECB is currently in the delicate process of shrinking its vast bond portfolio after years of hoovering up government and corporate debt, pressing another lever to bring down inflation.

READ: ECB can aim for soft landing for economy – Villeroy

Meanwhile geopolitical instability, particularly the potential fallout from the Israel-Hamas war, could trigger “another sharp rise in gas and oil prices that would push inflation upwards”, Eric Dor, director of economic studies at IESEG business school in France, told AFP.

How would ECB policymakers respond “at a time when the eurozone economy is already very fragile?” he asked.

‘Very difficult’

The 20-nation currency club’s economy shrank by 0.1 percent in the third quarter as consumers and businesses reeled from higher borrowing costs.


Should further shocks arise, Dor said Lagarde could be left facing the dilemma of either adopting a “wait-and-see approach” — knowing that the ECB already received criticism for reacting slower than other central banks when prices started climbing — or raising rates further.

Doing so would be “at the risk of causing a sharp recession, a property crash and a wave of defaults on private and public debt”, he added.

READ Euro zone PMI hits lowest in nearly 3 years, stirs recession worries

Analysts also see fundamental challenges on the horizon that could shake up monetary policy.

Fritzi Koehler-Geib, chief economist at German public lender KfW, said the economy was headed for “profound structural changes” as a result of the climate crisis, a shortage of skilled workers, weak productivity growth and mounting geopolitical conflicts.

The coming shifts could “make it very difficult” for the ECB to maintain its two-percent inflation goal in the future, Dor added.


Ever since she took on the job in November 2019, Lagarde’s “diplomatic skills” have proved “very useful” in smoothing over tensions after the ECB’s 25-member governing council was left deeply divided at the end of predecessor Mario Draghi’s term, Dor said.

The outbreak of the pandemic united ECB policymakers around the need to keep credit flowing to businesses and households and limit the economic damage from Covid-related shutdowns.

The result was a massive bond-buying scheme dubbed the Pandemic Emergency Purchase Program (PEPP), hashed out at Lagarde’s kitchen table in Frankfurt.

Lagarde, a former French finance minister and head of the International Monetary Fund, steered the ECB “safely through stormy times in the first half of her term”, said Koehler-Geib, praising the quick decision to launch PEPP.

But the post-pandemic recovery fueled inflation in the autumn of 2021 as supply chain disruptions led to numerous shortages, and the ECB’s response was, in hindsight, perhaps “a little too late”, she added.

Lagarde initially insisted the surge in consumer price growth would be temporary, and stuck to the ECB’s line that rates would stay low until a pre-pandemic asset purchasing scheme had ended in mid-2022.

That stance became harder to hold after Russia’s war in Ukraine sparked an energy crisis that pushed eurozone inflation to record highs.

Lagarde recently told the Financial Times she regretted having felt “bound by our forward guidance”.

“I should have been bolder,” she said.

The ECB’s dramatic gear change came in July 2022, when it kicked off the fastest rate-hiking cycle since the introduction of the euro, which “credibly demonstrated” a determination to restoring price stability, Koehler-Geib said.

While Lagarde has acknowledged the “pain” heaped on companies and citizens as they contend with more expensive loans and mortgages, she has said rates would be kept high for long enough to return inflation to target.

Your subscription could not be saved. Please try again.
Your subscription has been successful.

Subscribe to our daily newsletter

By providing an email address. I agree to the Terms of Use and acknowledge that I have read the Privacy Policy.

Any talk of when the ECB might start cutting rates was “totally premature”, Lagarde reiterated last week.

TAGS: ECB, energy costs, euro zone

© Copyright 1997-2024 | All Rights Reserved

We use cookies to ensure you get the best experience on our website. By continuing, you are agreeing to our use of cookies. To find out more, please click this link.