‘Unpredictability’ of Chinese laws worries foreign firms, says EU official
European Commission Vice President Vera Jourova speaks during a press conference on the EU-China High level digital dialogue in Beijing on Sept 19, 2023. (Photo by Jade Gao / AFP)
BEIJING, China -The European Commission’s digital chief said Tuesday that murky Chinese laws were fueling concerns among foreign firms in the country, following discussions with Beijing officials about critical areas such as AI and data governance.
Vera Jourova, who is also the commission’s vice president, made the comments after talks on Monday with Chinese counterparts including Vice Premier Zhang Guoqing in the second “High-level Digital Dialogue” between the two sides.
Among the concerns Jourova said she had heard about from European businesses in China was the “unpredictability of the decisions and interpretation of the laws by the regulators”.
Beijing has recently implemented expansive new regulations covering cybersecurity, counterespionage and data management, citing the need to shore up national security measures.
READ: China approves wide-ranging expansion of counter-espionage law
But the new regulations have worried some foreign firms, unsure of how their enforcement will affect their business operations in the world’s second-largest economy.
“First thing is the not very clear wording of the laws, especially missing definitions of, for instance, what is ‘important data’, and what… the companies could be confronted with when transferring the data outside,” Jourova told reporters.
Jourova also criticized the “lengthy procedures” foreign firms must undergo to conduct business in the country.
“I think it’s 45 days for one process — it lasts very often a much longer time,” she said.
“Nobody is criticizing the Chinese laws, we just want them to be clear and relatively easy to comply with.”
The EU official and Czech politician’s visit to Beijing comes just days after Brussels announced a probe into Chinese subsidies for electric vehicles, which it said had resulted in unfair competition.
China warned that the investigation would have a negative impact on its trade relations with the bloc, accusing it of “naked protectionism”.
Jourova said she emphasized during her meetings with Chinese officials the concerns of European firms over increasingly difficult business conditions in the country, as well as the implications of AI on human rights in the country’s northwestern Xinjiang region.
China is accused of incarcerating more than a million Uyghurs and other Muslim minorities in a network of detention facilities across Xinjiang, although Beijing insists its actions have helped to combat extremism and enhance development.
Deteriorating ties between China and the West in recent years have given rise to concerns in Brussels over the potential vulnerabilities posed by AI, misinformation, and data security.
European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen has called on the EU to define its own approach to Beijing, although some of Europe’s larger powers want to be cautious to avoid severing business ties.
READ: EU chief wants ‘level playing field’ with China
“The EU does not seek to de-couple from China,” Jourova said.
“But we need to improve our resilience and competitiveness by de-risking our economic interdependencies and advancing our technology security agenda in order to remain competitive and protect our essential European interests.”
China has pushed back on the “de-risking” strategy espoused by Washington and its European allies.
A foreign ministry spokesperson said in June that “anyone seeking to ‘de-risk’ against China is getting their target wrong and will only create real risks”.
