Tumbling exports feed worker unrest in world’s factory China

BEIJING  – Strikes at Chinese factories have surged to a seven-year high and are expected to become more frequent as weak global demand forces exporters to cut workers’ pay and shut down plants, one rights group and economists say.

Exports and factory output in the world’s second-largest economy tumbled in May, as looming downturns force the United States and Europe to pare back orders for goods made in China.

China’s exports tumble in May, imports slow

Some factories closed or are struggling to pay wages or severance for laid-off workers as a result, according to Chinese labor researchers. That has led to a spike in labor disputes that hurts consumer and business confidence just as it was recovering from three years of COVID-19 curbs, they said.

“We believe that the drop in manufacturing orders and that factory closures will continue,” said Aidan Chau, researcher at Hong Kong-based rights group China Labor Bulletin (CLB).

“Bosses want to cut costs by simply dumping workers.”

CLB recorded over 140 strikes at factories across the country in the first five months of this year, the highest since the 313 recorded during the same period in 2016.

The rights group’s data is mostly based on protests reported on social media, some of which CLB has been able to verify through contact with unions or the factories, although not all reports are verified.

Many of the strikes are concentrated in China’s manufacturing heartland of Guangdong province and the Yangtze River Delta, and involve exporters, including from garment, shoe and printed circuit board factories, CLB said.

In one video referenced in CLB’s mapped log of nationwide strikes, dozens of female workers at Zhong Min Sportswear Goods Shenzhen Ltd. Co. walk out of a factory compound.

The video was published on May 24 on Douyin, China’s version of TikTok, and captioned “this boss paid off law enforcement and is cheating workers’ money”.

Another video posted by the same user shows a factory manager reading a document denying workers compensation, while workers demand that an independent third party intervene.

In another video published on May 26, a handful of workers stand on the roof of Shenzhen cable factory Xin Dian Cable Ltd. Co., holding a banner that says “the boss owes us wages”. Another video published last week shows the company’s workers debating compensation with a company lawyer.

“You need to collect workers’ grievances and pass them on,” one female worker says.

Reuters verified the location of the videos and photos through matching the signage and building features with street view data, but could not confirm the timing of the protests. Calls to Xin Dian went unanswered. A person picking up the phone at Zhong Min said she could not comment.

The Douyin users did not respond to messages from Reuters. Participants in protests are often monitored by security forces.

China’s Ministry of Public Security, Ministry of Human Resources, the Shenzhen police and the All-China Federation of Trade Unions – a state-run umbrella organization for all unions in the country – also did not respond.

Instability risks

Chinese factories, which produce a third of global manufactured goods, form complex supply chains that ultimately rely much more on exports than domestic demand, leading to giant trade surpluses in the $18 trillion economy.

China’s April data show economic recovery losing steam

Manufacturers make use of a workforce of hundreds of millions of rural migrants, many of whom are on temporary contracts or hired informally, labor activists say.

This leaves workers vulnerable to unpaid overtime, impromptu pay cuts, or layoffs without due process or compensation, as factories look to reduce costs.

Workers find it hard to win in any conflict. Security forces intervene early to disperse protesters and censors scrub evidence of disputes on social media.

Labor unions were central to the Communist Party’s proletariat beginnings but play only a marginal role in modern authoritarian China.

However, some analysts say factory strikes could become a political headache for the Party.

“Firms are adapting to the reality of overcapacity through pay cuts and layoffs,” said Xu Tianchen, senior China economist at the Economist Intelligence Unit.

Job and salary cuts “will not only be detrimental to growth, but could also become a source of instability,” Xu said.