Quantcast
Latest Stories

PH can drive a ‘sports car’ rather than a ‘jeepney’ economy if…

By

The Philippines can prove that it drives a “sports car” rather than a “jeepney” economy by embarking on further interest rate cuts and a more aggressive government spending given the challenging global environment, a Bank of the Philippine Islands research said.

With the negative backdrop of the European debt crisis, a floundering US recovery, the slowing of China and weakness in commodity prices, the Philippines might have no choice but to grow internally through government spending on infrastructure in tandem with stronger domestic private sector investment and consumption, according to a July 12 research written by the BPI financial markets group led by economist Emilio Neri Jr.

“The national government must ramp up efforts to spend on infrastructure to address backlogs in traditional growth drivers. At the same time, the BSP [Bangko Sentral ng Pilipinas] may help spur the domestic economy through some form of monetary easing in the near term to give the economy an added shot in the arm,” the research said.

The BPI research favored a fresh policy interest rate cut to a new record low of 3.75 percent or lower, which was in contrast to the mainstream view that the BSP would likely keep its overnight borrowing rate steady at 4 percent for the rest of the year. The BSP has slashed its key rates by 50 basis points earlier this year.

“These policies combined with efforts to increase our overall competitiveness can help the Philippines finally prove to the world that it has never been a ‘jeepney economy’ all these years but may have instead been a ‘race car’ all along—except that this time—it’s not about to run out of gas,” the research said.

The research noted that the domestic economy has managed to maintain a strong external position while growing above 6 percent. It said this meant that the Philippines was not about to overheat in the same fashion that it did in the 1980s and the 1990s when the root cause of sharp economic slowdowns and contractions were widening current account deficits and balance of payments (BOP) problems.

The BPI research said these observations also seemed to suggest that faster growth might not necessarily result in “demand pull” inflation given the large surplus of the labor force, which could lead to a slower increase in Philippine wages compared to nations with tighter labor supply.

“Demand pull” inflation occurs when consumer prices rise because demand is greater than supply or more commonly described as when there is “too much money chasing too few goods.”

The research noted that the Philippines was previously given the moniker “the jeepney economy,” in reference to its sub-par historical growth performance and extreme susceptibility to “overheating” or building inflationary pressures even at the slightest acceleration in gross domestic product (GDP).

When the 6.4-percent Philippine GDP growth rate for the first quarter was announced last May, it noted that the majority of conventional theorists concluded that the Philippines need not cut interest rates further despite headline inflation persistently ranging below the BSP’s 3-5 percent inflation target.

But aside from avoiding the usual contractions that historically followed six straight years of growth, the Philippines has broken the trend and managed to actually grow for 13 straight years since 1999.

On the other hand, it noted that Philippine economic growth prior to four contraction episodes in the past was always funded through leverage, which ultimately led to a sizeable build-up in external liabilities and the economy’s susceptibility to sudden stops in foreign capital flows.


Follow Us


Follow us on Facebook Follow on Twitter Follow on Twitter


Recent Stories:

Complete stories on our Digital Edition newsstand for tablets, netbooks and mobile phones; 14-issue free trial. About to step out? Get breaking alerts on your mobile.phone. Text ON INQ BREAKING to 4467, for Globe, Smart and Sun subscribers in the Philippines.

Short URL: http://business.inquirer.net/?p=71149

Tags: economy , Interest Rates , Philippines

  • Hayek SaMaynila

    This was prophetic. They were the only ones that saw this coming.

  • http://www.lifeinsuranceph.com/ Life Insurance Philippines

    Buti na lang jeepney economy at hindi kalabaw economy ang ginamit na baseline.

  • divictes

    We always have the solution to our problems, it’s the implementation that’s get waylaid somewhere.

  • http://profile.yahoo.com/RROK74RNVY4SPYGOOK46N3OZXM Ronnie Basit

    With the financial woes of Europe’s major economic industrialized and some sank into recession. All these, besides the political turmoil or with so mcuh political instability. On the other hand, ours displayed receptivity to new ideas which economy  has displayed strong resillience allowing the country to move from “jeepney economy” to a sport economy. It is due simply to hard work and a well-managed economic regime which economic performance has not been an accident, but rather of careful planning and sound policies.

  • http://www.blogspot.com/uniha Uniha

    A sports car definitely sounds way sexier than a jeepney. But it’s a false analogy. And the BPI paper is sexing up an analogy that could be disastrous for our economy. Lowering interest rates will only encourage leveraging and overleveraging which in the end pushes up prices of goods, commodities, rents and even land prices at the expense of ordinary folks. Haven’t these people learned from the lessons of the past? The overleveraged Lopezes who ended up having to divest from their water, toll road and more recently power businesses? Or the BSP’s speculative dabbling in foreign currency trading that resulted in huge losses in 2011 which it sugarcoated as forex hedging? Or GSIS’s losses under Garcia’s watch? But of course, there’s nothing surprising about BPI pushing for lower interest rates. Given the bleak global economy, leveraging and putting the lives of ordinary folks at risk is where the likes of BPI are going to make a quick buck or two.

    • Hayek SaMaynila

      Believe it or not, lowering peso (policy) interest rates can actually reduce overall leveraging in the Philippines. 

      Many Filipinos do not know it but they are actually leveraging in foreign currencies (not pesos) already and they may end up paying more for these liabilities, in the end.Ever wonder how some banks are able to offer very low mortgage rates, even if they don’t have branches to generate peso deposits from? These banks are able to find a way to raise very cheap funds from abroad which they are able to lend to Filipino clients. Why are we even surprised? Nearly all interest rates in the developed world bear near-zero interest rates these days. US rates at 0.0 to 0.25%, Japan rates at 0.0 to 0.10%. Recently, Europe has cut rates too from 1.0% to 0.75%. Their central banks even print money to purchase debt issued by their own governments (e.g.US Treasuries) or assets guaranteed by their governments (e.g. mortgage backed securities). This is what we call quantitative easing or QE, which is about to have a 3rd version in the US this year.Now if the PHL-BSP does not cut interest rates like the EU, China, South Korea, Brazil, or print money like the UK, Japan just this past week, all these cheap funds from abroad will just continue to flood our economy with their debased currencies because they will all want a piece of the 4.0% that the BSP offers and guess who pays for it: the ordinary Filipino taxpayer who is now saddled by expensive cost of utilities.Failure to cut policy rates could make the already strong peso even stronger and punish, among others, the  OFWs who have worked so hard to save our economy from debt.

      What the BSP/SEC can do to slow down leveraging is to regulate Financial institutions’ allocation and growth of their assets (loans, securities, etc.) and punish them if they violate certain limits.

      • http://www.blogspot.com/uniha Uniha

        Nice try Hayek. And thanks for the time and effort to enlighten us on your Austrian free-market economics. I have a patch in my backyard where I source garden variety vegetables from. I buy cheap Made.in.China shirts and wares that last me long. I drive an old japanese car I converted to allow biofuel. I also do my own composting. In short, I’m not much affected by food & fuel inflation due to quantitative easing or whichever central bank’s decision. In fact, many Filipinos on so-called subsistence farming or fishing or foraging are better off than in the so-called formal economy. And we’re happy that way. When the economy in those faraway fairy tale places recover, and they will just like all cycles of booms and busts, interest rates will go up and whatever foreign funds that have taken shelter on our shores temporarily will disappear faster than any split-second high-frequency trading transaction. Just like that. Last time it happened, Mr. Mahathir was even vilified for imposing a capital exit tax. But he got it right where everybody else got it wrong. Even Krugman in a roundabout way supported Mahathir in a Businessweek piece of his back in 98. I’m sure you have the best intentions and would like violators to be caught and prosecuted. But I wouldn’t bet too much on it, white collar crimes pay well. And they pay even more handsomely if the culprits are well connected. The Lopezes got away with sweetheart deals to unload their overleveraged assets instead of facing fraud and misrepresentation charges. The losses of GSIS under Garcia’ watch were never publicly scrutinized. Worse, BSP’s currency speculation losses in 2011 was glossed over as hedging losses. All because these big boring financial terms don’t catch much attention. And if you really care about people losing the value of their money, you wouldn’t be pushing for lower interest rates just because everybody else did the same thing. Just between you and me, I’m not even much affected by any of those. Because I have my money stored in nuggets buried under the ground. A century or two from now, they’ll still be worth the same thing and even more valuable than the fiat value of paper money. The Jews, Indians and Chinese have always stored money in gold or silver or gem stones. I’d rather entrust my wealth to some precious metal and stone than some theory.

      • Hayek SaMaynila

         It makes a big difference what currency one leverages in. The Lopezes leveraged in USD because BSP in the 1990s implicitly guaranteed a stable exchange rate and high domestic interest rates.

        And because PHP strength was unsustainable back then as OFs did not bring in as much USD yet, the Lopezes were hit by massive currency depreciation.

        Now if the BSP today adopts the same policy as the 1990s – keeping USD/PHP very steady or even strengthening and keeping domestic interest rates higher than foreign interest rates, we can end up in the same situation as the Asian Crisis.

        What BSP needs to do to avoid the mistake of the 1990s is to allow more USD/PHP volatility, consistent with low peso interest rates to discourage companies and individuals from leveraging in USD.

        BSP can afford to allow more currency volatility today because it now has the ammunition to counter speculation unlike the 1990s when PHL had very little international reserves. Like you, BSP is invested in around USD7.0Bn in gold.

        Capital controls as you suggested can also help and they are in the guise of “macroprudential measures”

        BSP’s hedging losses are peanuts compared to the billions it loses servicing SDAs which pay 4.0%.

        Nice try Uniha =)

      • http://www.blogspot.com/uniha Uniha

        Macroprudential measures? There you have it. Tax the capital outflow and phase them, to deter speculative inflow. As for the rest, you know you’re just trying to rationalize your untenable position. Neither you nor I have absolute control over the fundamental uncertainties of markets, more so during such a volatile time. There’s nothing macroeconomically prudent about applying the wrong solution to the problem.

      • Hayek SaMaynila

        This is not rationalization Uniha. Before accusing me of such,please take a minute and try to understand.

        Do you know that Money Supply growth is only 7.9% but growth of credit is around 20%? What does that say? It means that credit growth/leveraging is being funded by foreign funds, not pesos? 

        While the BSP has good intentions of keeping consumer price and asset inflation low by crowding out the private sector with its SDA facility (which has btw now ballooned to P1.7trillion), its policy mix is actually paving the way for bigger credit growth and an ever growing exposure of the government and the private sector to foreign liabilities.

        By keeping USD/PHP steady through intervention in the currency market while keeping domestic interest rates significantly higher than most other countries abroad, it will encourage excessive borrowing in foreign currencies again. (no exchange rate risk, low interest rates abroad).

        Bottom line, the peso should be allowed to depreciate faster during times of volatility (e.g. Greek exit uncertainty in May and June this year when PHP was headed towards 44) and should be combined with lower domestic interest rates. This mix will discourage leverage in foreign currencies and ensure that PHL labor remains competitive while corporates and government can raise PHP denominated funds at reasonable cost.

  • 8284

    Let us stop and enjoy this a little bit. Then let us build on top of it. Pnoy was. Correct. What wonders a little honesty and good governance can make !

    To doomsayers , the Tiglaos, Doronillas , Mitos , Coronas …be gone.

    Remember, this is happening while we are having a severe fued with China !

    What more if ..

  • Ted Windsor

    your jeepney economy is fueled by constant inflow of foreign currencies provided by the ever growing OFW remittances.  Observe the trend when a calamity hits a province – the peso appreciates.  This due to OFW relatives sending more money to reconstruct damaged properties.

    6.4 growth was due to less spending by the Aquino administration.  

    As for the your sports car economy it is vastly controlled by the driver (the elite) ordinary filipinos can only watch in awe as they speed away guzzling up the interests in exchange rates from hard earned OFW dollar remittance for their own personal pleasures.

  • carlcid

    A sports car economy where a very select few will travel in style while the rest will be walking by the wayside. Unless serious measures are taken to level the playing field and prevent the elite from capturing government and all opportunities, economic and otherwise, we will still be talking “trickle down”.

    • WeAry_Bat

       ’trickle down’ means a lesser economic level for the much larger populations below the ‘elites’.  this is not a stable situation.

      Having better, healthier classes in the lower and middle levels could lessen down economic shocks, ultimately, buffering these ‘elites’.



Copyright © 2013, .
To subscribe to the Philippine Daily Inquirer newspaper in the Philippines, call +63 2 896-6000 for Metro Manila and Metro Cebu or email your subscription request here.
Factual errors? Contact the Philippine Daily Inquirer's day desk. Believe this article violates journalistic ethics? Contact the Inquirer's Reader's Advocate. Or write The Readers' Advocate:
c/o Philippine Daily Inquirer Chino Roces Avenue corner Yague and Mascardo Streets, Makati City, Metro Manila, Philippines Or fax nos. +63 2 8974793 to 94
Advertisement

News

  • 14 party-lists win seats
  • How campaign ads catapulted Grace Poe
  • Proclaimed party-lists and their nominees
  • Senator Revilla backs down, ends Cavite political drama
  • Of 6 incumbents, Cayetano, Trillanes, Pimentel are the biggest gainers
  • Sports

  • Tigers, Falcons score; Blazers stun Tams
  • GM Paragua shares Asian chess top spot with Li
  • Dazed Beermen try to get back at Thais today
  • Sportswatch
  • Catalan, Lim lead Jr Masters champs
  • Lifestyle

  • Call center workers told to have more ‘sex’ in their lives
  • Imperial and ‘monarchic’ scent–it could only be French
  • ‘Asian fit’ menswear by way of Savile Row
  • Punk meets history in first Chanel show in Asia
  • Wild cinnamon bark tea, berry wine, coco sugar brownies–Hindy Tantoco’s ‘Balik Bukid’ buys
  • Entertainment

  • Demi Lovato is a work in progress
  • Stars’ ‘shameful’ secrets revealed
  • Penchant for loopy and messy details
  • Nora and Vilma go indie
  • Three inspiring real-life dramas at the polls
  • Business

  • GDP on track to meet 6-7% target
  • Stocks continue to decline
  • BSP chief says capital flight to spare PH
  • Imports contracted in Q1
  • MBC, FPI buck halt to oil smuggling case vs Phoenix
  • Technology

  • Yahoo takes big leap with $1.1B deal for Tumblr
  • Poll: More US teens turn to Twitter; Facebook old
  • Tips to avoid becoming an identity theft victim
  • Filipinos in flight want to go online
  • SMC pledges to put more capital in Liberty Telecom
  • Opinion

  • Brillantes’ tantrums
  • Pointed questions for the Comelec chair
  • Social enterprise as innovative business model
  • Perennial irony
  • Voters like election surveys
  • Global Nation

  • Kids make art to help rescue other kids from neglect
  • Dinagyang dancers to hit NY streets for PH Independence fest
  • Kin of slain fisherman unaware of PH apology
  • Lapid’s wife back in PH after US probation for cash smuggling—immigration exec
  • Russian’s Mayon caper cost gov’t P520 K
  • Marketplace
    Advertisement
    © Copyright 1997-2013 INQUIRER.net | All Rights Reserved
    skinner left
    skinner right