The ordeal of duped owners



(Fifth in a series)

Car dealerships, or casa, serve as the “face and hands” of the brand. The casa is where the interface between customer and manufacturer happens. It’s where a lasting personal or business relationship, or a lifetime of enmity, is formed. Here are two examples of the latter.

Dead on the highway

In 2011, Ruston Banal Jr., a freelance photographer and university professor, bought a brand-new China-made minivan worth about P500,000 in San Fernando, Pampanga, through  a bank loan.

He related to Inquirer Motoring that in less than three months after purchase, the engine developed a major problem. In one particularly frightening incident, the engine died while he was driving about 90 kph on the highway.

This happened again several times. Ruston related it would take him 10 to 15 attempts before the engine would restart. The clutch, which Ruston said was another problem altogether, made the vehicle stutter “like a horse” everytime he started the engine or shifted to first gear.

Ruston brought his vehicle back to the casa along with a complaint letter. The casa claimed it had all the problems fixed when it returned the vehicle to Ruston. But when he drove it home, the clutch problem was still there. Worse, the air-conditioning system was acting up, as well.

Soon afterwards, the engine started stalling once more. Then the battery, which was just a year old, became discharged.

Ruston took the vehicle back to the casa, but the service and repair department said that his vehicle was no longer under warranty.

Problems unresolved


“To my disappoinment, I left the casa and had it repaired by my relative-mechanic. Since the cost of the repair would be so expensive, especially in procuring the materials and parts, I only had the aircon repaired. The clutch and engine problems were unresolved.”

In October 2012, the clutch failed completely, and the gear wouldn’t shift. Ruston had the MPV towed to his relative’s shop. The clutch repair set him back P10,000. Still, the issue of the stalling engine was untouched.

Ruston talked to the vehicle dealer’s marketing manager, who offered to take the vehicle in for evaluation. Ruston agreed and took the vehicle back to the casa.

SASI. Photo by Tessa R. Salazar

After several weeks, the casa called and charged Ruston P22,000 for the “evaluation” and repair services.

That was the final straw. After paying a quarter of a million pesos for the vehicle since 2011, an exasperated Ruston said he was no longer interested to pay any more monthly amortizations on the vehicle.

“I am willing to have it repossessed (in Ruston’s word, ‘ipahila’) even if it means all my previous monthly payments would have gone with the wind. This is grossly unfair! But before that, I will file a complaint to the DTI (Department of Trade and Industry) as well as ask for a demand letter from a lawyer about this.”

Not alone

Ruston claims he is not alone in this nightmare. He said he knows of other owners of the same vehicle who have experienced the same problems.

Ramil Sasi, an instructor at a premier university in Manila, bought his family’s first brand-new mini MPV (2010 model) from a brand he admired most. In his own words, the quality of the automaker had been “very satisfactory, having tried several old models or second-hand cars made by it”. He bought this automaker’s MPV as it also fit his family’s modest budget.

One time, he took the vehicle to its Manila casa for the scheduled PMS (preventive maintenance service). Included in the service was the so-called brake cleaning, costing several hundred pesos and would require taking the hub caps, and the tires, off.

Puzzled with service

After claiming the vehicle and driving it back home, Ramil noticed that the nylon cord he customarily tied over his wheels’ hub caps to prevent them from falling were untouched. They were fastened exactly the way he left them when he brought it to the casa for servicing. “How could the casa people have performed the brake cleaning without removing the hub caps and tires?” he wondered.

Ramil aired this observation when the casa called up to follow up on its after-service. “There was no return call after that, to apologize or anything, so I never returned to that casa after that.”

Ramil decided to have his MPV’s next PMS done at a casa nearer his home in Cavite. He said he was initially delighted to see that the customers of this casa could lounge on the second floor and see their vehicles being serviced. And so, Ramil watched his MPV being serviced from his second-floor vantage point.

Among the services performed on Ramil’s vehicle that day, and which was charged to him, was for the tightening of bolts costing a few hundred pesos. But here’s the catch: Ramil said he never saw his vehicle raised on the lifter, which would be a prerequisite for the service. He insisted that the whole time he was there, he also never saw any one of the mechanics performing the service. Ramil also checked if there were marks on the bolts that would suggest they were tightened and found that there were none.

“I relayed my complaint, but no attempt of reparations came. I even remember that I had to ask the service advisor to return the excess of nearly a liter of synthetic oil since I bought four liters of oil, as the casa requested, when in fact the car needs only three liters of oil.”

Ramil concluded: “After those horrendous experiences I now hesitate to ever come back to any casa again. All I am doing now is get pointers from social networking sites, and research for better services for my car.”

(To be continued)

Share your casa stories— pleasant or unpleasant—to

Get Inquirer updates while on the go, add us on these apps:

Inquirer Viber

Disclaimer: The comments uploaded on this site do not necessarily represent or reflect the views of management and owner of We reserve the right to exclude comments that we deem to be inconsistent with our editorial standards.

  • dickenhead

    lesson to learn: never trust china made vehicles; they suck

  • Leor Wong

    If you buy a branch new car and you have the PMS done in your trusted talyer, would the casa void your car’s warranty?

  • Armando Buena

    Parang alam ko ang brand na ito ah.I am also a 2nd hand auto car dealer in Pampanga. There’s a one China brand there on which I hear a lot of negative comments and complaints-it’s the HAMA na may Superstar yata o Star na brand label na brand ng biggest auto group in Central Luzon. This is particularly the mini van na sobrang rupok daw lalo na sa ilalim-clutch at bearing.
    Propessor ka na rin lang, sana naman nag research ka muna about sa brand.Dami naman magagandang brand dyan. Bat kasi CHINA pa.tsk..tsk.Yan tuloy, naglahong parang bula ang P250,000 mo.

  • henry21

    let’s all be aware of what they do. 
    my experience was dated back in 90’s. my front bumper was damaged by a jeepney. since it is under warranty and with comprehensive insurance, I brought my 3 month old vehicle to the casa/dealer where I bought it. It was explained to me that they will replace it with new front bumper but will be charged to my insurance. I submitted required docs and presto, it took them 1 week to replace the damaged bumper.

    I was informed that it is now ready for pick-up. I was happy that it is now okey. While checking the vehicle before leaving the casa/dealer, I noticed that my aircon unit is not operating normally, I called the service advisor about this and he have it checked. Lo and behold!!! he said that my aircon is defective. I asked him bakit siya masisira e front bumper lang ang papalitan nyo?! I requested to talk to the service manager and told him what happened. He ask the unit to be checked thoroughly and found out that the aircon compressor is defective. I told him that this is a brand new unit (3 months old) how come the compressor is defective, upon further investigation they found out that my aircon compressor was replaced. it was not the original compressor unit installed. They said that they will replace the compressor with a new one. They apologized and promised that they will dig deeper to find out who replaced it with a defective compressor.The casa owner are also a victim of their own people. We should call the attention of the Management for them to know what is happening in their own turf. In my case, I asked my brother/lawyer to write them. The casa even provide me a discount every time they will serviced my vehicle. 

    Fight for our Rights!!!

To subscribe to the Philippine Daily Inquirer newspaper in the Philippines, call +63 2 896-6000 for Metro Manila and Metro Cebu or email your subscription request here.

Factual errors? Contact the Philippine Daily Inquirer's day desk. Believe this article violates journalistic ethics? Contact the Inquirer's Reader's Advocate. Or write The Readers' Advocate:

c/o Philippine Daily Inquirer Chino Roces Avenue corner Yague and Mascardo Streets, Makati City,Metro Manila, Philippines Or fax nos. +63 2 8974793 to 94


editors' picks



latest videos